Thursday, June 19, 2014

Day Four: The Shadow Falls on the Shire



Poor Frodo. It was frightening enough to learn that the ring was the One Ring (note the capital letters Tolkien uses) and that it had come into his possession. How much worse is it to find out that the Enemy has wormed information out of Gollum, information that has brought the name of hobbit, Shire, and perhaps even Baggins to the attention of evil?

I love the way Frodo surprises Gandalf in this scene, with his quiet resolve to do the right thing in leaving the Shire with the ring. You can tell that this decision comes less from fear (though understandably there is an element of that) and more from a motivation to protect all those he loves in the Shire, and to fulfill his responsibility as the owner of the ring.

Of course, Frodo has no way yet of knowing just how heavy that ring-bearing responsibility will ultimately be. Near the end of this second chapter, he tries to give it away to Gandalf, an action that horrifies the old wizard because it throws so much temptation in his path. He knows the ring is much safer in Frodo’s hands, partly because Frodo still doesn’t fully understand its power (though he’s beginning to grasp its near indestructibility) and partly because Frodo doesn’t have a desire for power.

I find it fascinating that Gandalf sees a power behind Bilbo’s coming upon the ring – a strong power that is different form the evil power involved in the making of the ring, the power that tries to draw the ring back. The fact that Gandalf sees this as “encouraging” shows he believes it to be a good power, working for good – and working for good through these small and unlikely chosen hobbits. It’s really our first glimpse at providence in the story.

Aragorn gets his first mention here, as the gifted huntsman and tracker who helps Gandalf find Gollum after the wizard loses track of him. And Sam gets a wonderful scene where he’s literally pulled into the room through the window to be glowered at by a bristly Gandalf who ends up laughing over Sam’s eavesdropping (perhaps catching yet another glimpse of providence? though he doesn’t say so) and deciding to send him along with Frodo. One of the wisest decisions he makes in the entire series, though it’s made in a moment of merriment. Perhaps that should tell us something about merry moments.

Oh, and I think I found my Sam voice last night. A little rushed, a little country bumpkin, excited and enthused. “Me, sir!...Me go and see Elves and all! Hooray!”

2 comments:

  1. One of my very favorite moments in the trilogy is Sam getting recruited - and how different his reaction here is from in the movie! I so love the image of him springing up like a dog invited for a walk. The enthusiasm is just palpable. He really has no idea what he's getting himself into, but it all feels like a grand adventure, a chance to be a part of one of those stories he's always loved. Frodo's sense of the journey ahead is grimmer, but his determination in the face of that is admirable.

    I love the role of providence in Lord of the Rings. It definitely does feel as though certain things are meant to happen, and for the ultimate good. The moment that captures that idea best for me is the one with Sam and the star as he and Frodo are approaching Mount Doom: “There, peeping among the cloud-wrack above a dark tower high up in the mountains, Sam saw a white star twinkle for a while. The beauty of it smote his heart, as he looked up out of the forsaken land, and hope returned to him. For like a shaft, clear and cold, the thought pierced him that in the end the Shadow was only a small and passing thing: there was light and high beauty for ever beyond its reach.”

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really need to see the movie again! I struggled a lot with the films' interpretation of Sam in general, but don't always remember individual moments and why they bothered me. (D. and I agree we think the problems with Sam were more inherent in the script than Sean Astin's fault.) In the book, his enthusiasm is indeed palpable...and sweet. He DOES remind you of a dog getting to go for a walk or a ride (sort of like Tock in Phantom Tollbooth!)

    The white star moment is such a lovely one...and puts me in mind yet again of Elbereth.

    ReplyDelete